empty
01.02.2022 11:23 PM
Traditional hedging schemes did not work: January brought losses to holders of standard investment portfolios

One of the most popular long-term investment schemes - a portfolio split 60/40 between stocks and high-quality bonds - showed the worst performance in January 2022 since the market crash in the early days of the pandemic.

Traditional hedging schemes did not work: January brought losses to holders of standard investment portfolios

Prices of both stocks and bonds fell sharply in January thanks to the Federal Reserve's hasty hawkish policy at the end of that year. The hawkish reversal intensified after last week's policy meeting, when leading Wall Street economists pushed for a rate hike of at least 1 point this year.

This image is no longer relevant

The Bloomberg 60/40 composite index, which tracks the trend of such investments, lost 4.2% in January due to a wide drop in large-cap stocks by 5.6%. This is the worst indicator after a 7.7% drop in March 2020, when the economy idled due to quarantine.

Investors still believe that the market is highly dependent on the Fed's next steps and the subsequent impact on inflation, economic growth and corporate earnings during the upcoming rate hike cycle.

It has now become obvious to everyone that increased inflation can force the Fed to become more aggressive and cause higher market volatility, undermining the effectiveness of diversified portfolios over a long period.

But bonds also did not lag behind traditionally more profitable stocks.

Benchmark Treasury yields were down two basis points to 1.75% as of 6:36 a.m. in New York after surging 27 basis points in January, the biggest gain in ten months.

"We can see a stagflationary environment where stocks and bonds are falling as a result of constant inflation and low growth," says Nancy Davis, chief investment officer.

Investors who own a long-term combination of stocks and bonds as a hedge fund need only look back at 2018 to understand that the tightening of the Fed may well lead to negative yields.

The 60/40 strategy brought losses to its owners of 2.3% in 2018, which was the second largest loss since the creation of the Bloomberg index in 2007 (the primacy belongs to the crisis year 2008).

Popular model fails

The 60/40 strategy became popular back in the 1980s. Over the longer term, it consistently delivers a 10% annual return and is a popular model for most Americans' retirement plans offered by asset managers.

The attraction of a diversified investment approach is that negative fluctuations for both stocks and bonds have usually been short-lived in the past.

Quality bonds, such as Treasuries, are traditionally less volatile than stocks and tend to rise in value when risky assets fall sharply. In turn, stocks make the most of their earnings over time as companies have steadily increased their earnings outside of a recession.

Alas, with the introduction of the low interest rate regime, the portfolio seems to have ceased to be a reliable investment vehicle.

For most of the last decade, the strong performance of 60/40 portfolio holdings reflected a climate of very low inflation, limited growth in bond yields, and a booming stock market. This has resulted in a challenging environment for generating future earnings as both stock and bond valuations ended at a high level in 2021.

Investors are looking for new opportunities

Before the notable decline in the 60/40 this month, investors have repeatedly looked for ways to abandon this approach.

For example, some argue for a downgrade of the bond component because the high-quality fixed-rate yield is below the current rate of inflation, which reduces the yield's purchasing power.

Others believe a move away from high-priced big US stocks to lower value smaller stocks in global markets such as the UK, Europe and emerging markets could help.

Another option was to actively invest in the private debt market for a long time in an attempt to find assets that are less correlated with those of publicly traded stocks and bonds.

"Our approach to 60/40 strategies is to own more dividend-paying stocks and allocate more to alternatives while undervaluing bonds," said investment strategist Anthony Saglimbene.

Employee at Citigroup Inc. Alex Saunders also noted last week that adjusting portfolios when growth slows and inflation remains high by "re-allocating a 60/40 portfolio to real estate, CTAs, quality capital...provide similar returns with less volatility and more stable performance across modes."

Ultimately, the lack of prospects for one of the most stable investment schemes tells us that the economy is inexorably changing. Low interest rates force investors to redraw traditional schemes in search of the most optimal instruments. On the other hand, it also serves as a reminder to us that delegating the management of your money can have consequences if your fund remains committed to conservative views. Personal investing (trading) with a deep study of market laws is likely to become the leading model for the future organization of stock and other financial markets.

A classic confirmation of this is Warren Buffett, who is the only one from the top of Forbes, did not lose, but earned on the fall in January, promptly redistributing his investments.

In addition, the failure of traditional investment schemes will necessarily cause a certain number of bankruptcies among hedge funds, and after them, boomer Americans who have just retired. Americans' well-being may falter in the long run.

Egor Danilov,
Analytical expert of InstaForex
© 2007-2025
Select timeframe
5
min
15
min
30
min
1
hour
4
hours
1
day
1
week
Earn on cryptocurrency rate changes with InstaForex
Download MetaTrader 4 and open your first trade
  • Grand Choice
    Contest by
    InstaForex
    InstaForex always strives to help you
    fulfill your biggest dreams.
    JOIN CONTEST

Recommended Stories

Boeing climbs, Best Buy falls as investors rebalance across sectors

Best Buy shares fell after the company cut its full-year sales and earnings forecasts. Boeing, on the other hand, gained ground as its CEO announced plans to ramp up production

13:49 2025-05-30 UTC+2

US Market News Digest for May 30

The S&P 500 opened the session on a positive note but soon reversed course after officials clarified that previously overturned tariffs would remain in place pending the outcome

Ekaterina Kiseleva 12:20 2025-05-30 UTC+2

Boeing Gains, Best Buy Falls: Why Investors Are Betting on Different Assets

Best Buy Falls After Full-Year Sales, Profit Outlook Shrink Boeing Gains as CEO Looks to Boost 737 MAX Production Japan's Nikkei Lagging as Yen Strengthens on Safe Haven Demand Indices

Thomas Frank 10:10 2025-05-30 UTC+2

US Market News Digest for May 29

Markets reacted to a US Court of International Trade ruling that found the Trump administration's tariff actions exceeded its authority. The decision has introduced fresh uncertainty for the S&P

Ekaterina Kiseleva 11:15 2025-05-29 UTC+2

Stock storm: Nvidia soars, Dow falls, court knocks down Trump tariffs

Nvidia shares up 5% after close; co reports quarterly results Dick's Sporting Goods rises after Q1 results beat expectations US trade court blocks Trump tariffs European stocks rise

Thomas Frank 10:49 2025-05-29 UTC+2

From Nvidia to Xiaomi: What's Driving Stock Market Growth and Decline Today

Indices Rising: Dow 1.78%, S&P 500 2.05%, Nasdaq 2.47% Consumer Confidence Recovers in May Temu Parent PDD Holdings Falls on Quarterly Revenue Slip Chinese Xiaomi Shares Set to Rise 2.3%

Thomas Frank 12:06 2025-05-28 UTC+2

Whoever doesn't risk a recession doesn't reduce the national debt? Trader's calendar on May 29–31

To be at the center of global attention and to "shape the planet's destiny" — that's what Donald Trump enjoys most. For him, it's essential to constantly generate headlines

Svetlana Radchenko 11:47 2025-05-28 UTC+2

US Market News Digest for May 28

The S&P 500 index has broken through the key 5,908 level, signaling the end of its recent correction and opening the door to further upside. A break above the resistance

Ekaterina Kiseleva 11:25 2025-05-28 UTC+2

US Market News Digest for May 27

US President Donald Trump announced a 50% tariff on imports from the EU, yet financial markets responded with restraint. Investors are increasingly adopting a "threat and retreat" strategy, buying stocks

Ekaterina Kiseleva 11:54 2025-05-27 UTC+2

Nvidia on the agenda: markets await quarterly report, dollar nears fifth straight monthly decline

Stock markets showed mixed dynamics on Tuesday after Donald Trump unexpectedly postponed the introduction of the promised 50% tariffs on goods from the European Union. The move only increased uncertainty

Thomas Frank 11:31 2025-05-27 UTC+2
Can't speak right now?
Ask your question in the chat.
Widget callback
 

Dear visitor,

Your IP address shows that you are currently located in the USA. If you are a resident of the United States, you are prohibited from using the services of InstaFintech Group including online trading, online transfers, deposit/withdrawal of funds, etc.

If you think you are seeing this message by mistake and your location is not the US, kindly proceed to the website. Otherwise, you must leave the website in order to comply with government restrictions.

Why does your IP address show your location as the USA?

  • - you are using a VPN provided by a hosting company based in the United States;
  • - your IP does not have proper WHOIS records;
  • - an error occurred in the WHOIS geolocation database.

Please confirm whether you are a US resident or not by clicking the relevant button below. If you choose the wrong option, being a US resident, you will not be able to open an account with InstaForex anyway.

We are sorry for any inconvenience caused by this message.